Where to get Peanut Butter Cup ice cream in NJ
69 stands we've found serving Peanut Butter Cup ice cream, by county.
Cape May County (15)
- Springer's Homemade Ice Cream · Stone Harbor
- Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill · Cape May
- The Ice Cream Station · Cape May Court House
- Custard King · Ocean View
- Marita's Homemade Ice Cream · Sea Isle City
- Custard Hut · Ocean View
- Aunt Betty's Ice Cream Shack · Ocean City
- Aunt Betty's Ice Cream Shack · Ocean City
- The Dugout Ice Cream · Wildwood
- Kings Ice Cream Parlour · Cape May
- Scoops on Sunset · West Cape May
- Custard Castle · Marmora
- Jurassic Swirled (at Jurassic Adventure Golf) · North Wildwood
- Scoop Deville Wildwood · North Wildwood
- Mister Softee · Wildwood
Other (14)
- Del Ponte's Bakery · Bradley Beach
- Gil & Bert's Ice Cream · Cranbury
- Cream Valley Custard · Woodstown
- The Whole Scoop · Bellmawr
- Dairy Queen · Oakland
- Hinlickity’s Ice Cream Parlor · Highlands
- Broadway Scoops · Pennsville
- Harvey Cedars Ice Cream Parlour · Harvey Cedars
- Moo’s Creamery · Egg Harbor Township
- Kaboodles Ice Cream · Normandy Beach
- LICK · Swedesboro
- George's Ice Cream · Ocean City
- Mister Softee · Seaside Heights
- Off The Rails Handcrafted Ice Cream & Shakes · Towaco
Ocean County (6)
- Iceberg Ice Cream · Lavallette
- Summer Sweets Ice Cream Shop in Lavallette, NJ · Lavallette
- The Original Rich's Ice Cream · Manahawkin
- Scoop City · Surf City
- Salty's Inlet Ice Cream · Point Pleasant Beach
- The Windmill Belgian Waffles & Ice Cream · Beach Haven
Monmouth County (5)
- Days Ice Cream · Ocean Grove
- Polar Bear Ice Cream · North Middletown
- Bradley’s Beach Plum · Bradley Beach
- Ryan's Homemade Ice Cream · Oakhurst
- Bruster's Real Ice Cream · Oceanport
Essex County (3)
- Venchi Chocolate & Gelato Short Hills · Short Hills
- Village Ice Cream Parlour · Maplewood
- Carvel · Nutley
Middlesex County (3)
- Magnifico's Ice Cream · East Brunswick
- Colonia Dairy Maid · Colonia
- Scoop to My Lou · East Brunswick
Morris County (3)
- Last Licks · East Hanover
- Scoops · Chatham
- Mendham Creamery · Mendham
Atlantic County (3)
- Custard Hut · Somers Point
- Custard's Last Stand · Ventnor City
- Willow's Way Shore Refreshments · Ventnor City
Passaic County (2)
- Gelotti Ice Cream · Paterson
- Carvel · Wayne
Burlington County (2)
- White Dotte Dairy Bar · Southampton Township
- Bordentown Creamery · Bordentown
Bergen County (2)
- Carvel · Hackensack
- 16 Handles · Teterboro
Gloucester County (2)
- Twin Kiss Drive In · Clayton
- Scoopy’s Too · Deptford
Camden County (2)
- Hilltop Creamery · Blackwood
- Cabana Water Ice Co. · Haddon Heights
Cumberland County (2)
- Del's Custard & Yogurt · Vineland
- Terry's Custard · Bridgeton
Hudson County (1)
- Harvy's · Jersey City
Sussex County (1)
- Dairy Swirl · Vernon Township
Hunterdon County (1)
- Jimmy's Ice Cream · Milford
Union County (1)
- Magic Fountain · Summit
Somerset County (1)
- As You Like It · Raritan
Flavors change often and vary by day. Spotted Peanut Butter Cup somewhere we missed?