✓ Water ice confirmed Hinlickity’s Ice Cream Parlor
120 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732, USA
★ 4.7 (138)
Old-timey creamery for a variety of flavors, sodas and desserts, plus outdoor seats. — summary via Google
Prices
Water ice · $3.99
From photos, calls, and visitor reports. May be out of date or vary by location.
We don't have a recent price here. Know the 2026 price?
Snap the menu board or type in what a medium costs. Takes 20 seconds and keeps the index honest.
Water ice flavors (9)
CherryLemonChocolateRainbowWatermelonMangoPINEAPPLECARAMELWHIPPED
Seasonal / limited-time
Amaretto LiqueurCinnamon
Also scoops ice cream (44 flavors)
VanillaChocolateStrawberryCherry VanillaChocolate Peanut ButterChocolate CherryHard Ice CreamSoft ServeChocolate Chip Cookie DoughButter PecanSea Salt Caramel PretzelMudslideApple PieCookie DoughPeanut Butter CupRocky RoadCappuccinoCookie/Cookies & CreamBlack RaspberryChocolate Chip MintToasted CoconutVanilla Peanut Butter SwirlCoconutCreamsicleCookies & CreamCinnamonPeachBananaCake BatterHoly CannoliRum RaisinCoco LocoPistachioSundaeCheesecakeSea Salt CaramelPretzelBlack RoseberryBrown CowOrange Cream
+ 4 more
Also on the menu
Italian IceHard Ice CreamSoft ServeMalt ShakesWafflesOld Fashion Soda Fountain Treatsice creamsodasdessertsSwirlice_creamhomemade_fudgehard_ice_creamconesPopeye Protein Shake
Good to know
Indoor counterIndoor seatingStreet parking
From stand photos. Double-check before a special trip.
More photos
