Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

225 Newark Pompton Turnpike Unit C-2, Pequannock Township, NJ 07440, USA

Rita's Calls it water ice & Italian ice ★ 4.5 (272)

Prices

Water ice · $3.87

From photos, calls, and visitor reports. May be out of date or vary by location.

We don't have a recent price here. Know the 2026 price?

Snap the menu board or type in what a medium costs. Takes 20 seconds and keeps the index honest.

Water ice flavors (36)

PiñA ColadaFlorida OrangeRoot BeerChocolateLemonWatermelonOcean SplashWild Black CherrySwedish FishCookies N' Cream Cream IceBlue RaspberryCherryMangoCotton CandySugar-Free Mango-PeachSugar-Free Dragon FruitUnicornMint Chocolate ChipVanillaPina ColadaStrawberry WatermelonKiwi MelonSugar-Free Mango PeachBananaMango StrawberryCoconut CreamCookiesCreamBlackberryChocolate Vanilla TwistStrawberry BananaBlack RaspberryPistachioCake BatterCoffeeSwedish Fish®

Seasonal / limited-time

Sour Blue Pucker IceShamrock Cream IceOcean Splash

Also scoops ice cream (10 flavors)

ChocolateTwistVanillaSalted CaramelOrange Cream CustardCoconut Cream Cream IceCheesecakeFudge Brownie Cream IceMint Chocolate Chip Cream IceOreo Cookies N' Cream Cream Ice