Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, USA

Calls it water ice ★ 4.8 (171)

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cheesecake and pumpkin pie flavors, plus cones and sundaes. — summary via Google

Prices

Small · $2.95 · Jul 2023 Regular · $4.95 · Jul 2023 Quart · $8.95 · Jul 2023

Newest price we have for each size, with the month it was observed (from menu-board photos and 2026 phone calls). May vary by location.

These prices are from 2023. Know the 2026 price?

Snap the menu board or type in what a medium costs. Takes 20 seconds and keeps the index honest.

Water ice flavors (11)

MangoCherryWatermelonPina ColadaBlueberryLemonRainbowCotton CandyChocolateCandy FishPiñA Colada

Also scoops ice cream (54 flavors)

VanillaChocolateStrawberryButter PecanSoft ChocolateChocolate ChipVanilla ChipCookies & CreamBrownie Chunk BlastPistachioBlueberry CheesecakeCoconutBanana 99 Moose TracksBlack RaspberryPeanut Butter RippleChocolate Peanut Butter SwirlMoose TracksCoffeeSalted Caramel PretzelRocky RoadDouble Fudge BrownieToffee Bar CrunchCinnamon ChurroEspresso ChipVanilla YogurtClassic ChocolateBirthday CakeChocolate Chip Cookie DoughMint Chocolate ChipNutellaChocolate Brownie BitesSoft VanillaChocolate Or TwistLayered Water IceVanilla BeanBananaButter Pecan Ice CreamSoft Chocolate Ice CreamChocolate Ice Cream, Nutella, Brownie BitesVanilla Chip Ice Cream

+ 14 more

Also on the menu

Water IceSoft ServeHard Ice CreamGelatiMilkshakesConesShakesSundaesNoveltiesBanana SplitsSpecialty SundaesFrozen CustardHershey's Ice CreamJack Jill's Ice Creamcones